Subscribe to our newsletter!
We don't spam. You will only receive relevant and important tips for you and your business.
Unsubscribe anytime.
By Darren DeYoung
Hire for the result you need. A good designer gives you a site customers trust. More calls and booked jobs take marketing built into that site. A tree, landscape, painting, garage door or rental business needs both. The simplest fix is one team that designs the site and is also on the hook for the calls it brings in.
A web designer shapes how the site looks and works. A marketing agency is measured by what the site does after launch: calls, quote requests, booked jobs. Both are real skills. Design earns a customer's trust in the first few seconds. Marketing gets that customer to the site and turns the visit into a call.
Here's how it usually breaks down:
| Design-only shop | Marketing-only agency | One team for both (Hoist) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Done when | Site approved | Phone rings | Jobs booked |
| Tracks | Pages, launch | Calls, forms | Calls, forms, jobs |
| After launch | Fixes, if paid | Works around the site | Keeps tuning it |
| SEO | Extra hire | In the plan | Built in |
| Copy | Yours | Written for search | Written with the design |
If your phone already rings and you only need a better look, a good designer may be all you need. If you need more calls, you need the marketing half too.
Not sure which to fix first? Here's how to decide whether to rebuild the website first or hire marketing.
One team means nobody can blame the other half. When a designer builds the site and a separate agency markets it, a drop in calls turns into finger-pointing. When the same team owns both, the people who see the call data can change the page that day. That's how Hoist works.
Precision Landscape & Tree is the clearest example. The company relied on directories and mailers until that market dried up. Hoist built Precision a modern website first, then drove homeowners to it with content, social media, review management, paid ads and conversion work.
What Precision's case study reports:
The marketing side works on its own, too. A Garage Door And Gate Store was booked out for six months after Hoist started managing its Google Ads campaigns.
It costs the jobs that slip away after launch day. The site looks new, but calls stay flat, the quote form sends to an old inbox, and the pages that used to bring in work quietly disappear from Google. You paid for the build, and now you're paying again to find out what broke.
Signs your new site isn't bringing in work:
That last one matters as much as the site. A lead that waits two days for a callback is a lead a competitor booked. Faster response times close more of the work you already paid to get.
Ask three things: who owns the leads after launch, what happens to your Google rankings, and how you'll know it worked in 90 days. A design-only shop answers with deliverables. A team that does design and marketing answers with your phone, your towns, and your booked jobs.
👍 Good answer: "Forms and calls go to your office, they're tracked, and we check monthly that nothing's going to a dead inbox."
🚩 Red flag: "That's handled by your contact form." Then silence. Call tracking shows which pages bring calls, so ask whether it's included.
👍 Good answer: "We map every old page to its new address and set up permanent redirects before launch."
That's straight from Google's site move guide, which says to prepare a URL mapping and redirect old URLs to new ones. Google also recommends permanent server-side redirects whenever possible.
🚩 Red flag: a blank look. If your rankings already dipped after a redesign, here's why that happens.
👍 Good answer: a short list of numbers they'll report: calls, form fills, and which pages brought them in.
In Google Analytics 4, form submissions and calls can be set up as key events. Ask who sets them up and who reads them. Measuring the right things is how you tell a site that's working from one that's just new.
🚩 Red flag: "You'll see more traffic." Traffic doesn't pay your employees. Booked jobs do.
Read what the proposal promises to deliver. If it only lists layouts, page counts and revision rounds, it's a design project. If it names calls, quote requests and booked jobs, and says how they'll be tracked, it's a marketing plan. The best proposals cover both, because the site and the marketing should come from the same team.
A proposal that covers both usually includes:
Hoist designs your site and runs the marketing behind it, so one team answers for how it looks and how often the phone rings. Tell us what you do and which towns you serve. We'll show you what a plan built around calls and booked jobs looks like for your business, with the 90-day numbers spelled out.
Talk to Hoist about your website
Already holding a proposal from someone else? Bring it. We'll walk through what it covers and what it leaves out.
Still comparing? Do the 10-minute lookup to see where your current site loses work, or browse our results.