Why You Should Always A/B Test Your Website

By Elin Enrooth

If you’re not A/B testing your website, you’re missing out on huge optimization opportunities.

Why You Should Always A/B Test Your Website

What is A/B testing?

A/B testing refers to the randomized experimentation process of comparing two or more versions of a webpage, email, or other asset with changes to a single variable. This change can be as simple as a single headline or button, or a complete page redesign.

The original version of the page is called the “control,” and the page with the changed variable is called the “variation.” These pages are shown to segments of website visitors at random and then engagement is measured and analyzed to determine which resonated best.

Essentially, A/B testing eliminates the guesswork out of website optimization. For example, if your phone call call-to-action (CTA) button is green and you believe that you would receive more calls if the button was red, an A/B test will prove whether that’s true or not.

What are the benefits of A/B testing?

A/B testing is one of the most cost-effective ways to evaluate visitor behavior. Even the simplest changes can impact conversion rates. This process helps you make incremental improvements to your website, giving you the ability to anticipate which changes to your website will be best received by visitors.

Solve visitor pain points

Visitors come to your website to achieve a specific goal. Whether it’s to learn more about your brand, purchase a product, or browse, they may encounter some common pain points, such as confusing copy or a hard-to-find CTA button.

This leads to a bad user experience, which increases friction and eventually impacts your conversion rates. Data collected during A/B testing can expose which areas of your site are pain points and be used to fix these issues.

Improve the ROI from existing traffic

A/B testing helps you make the most out of your existing traffic without having to spend more to acquire new traffic. It can help you achieve a higher return on investment (ROI) as sometimes even the smallest of changes on your website can result in a significant increase in conversions.

Reduce bounce rate

One of the most important metrics to judge your website’s performance is bounce rate. There may be many reasons behind a website’s high bounce rate, such as a slow loading time, misleading title tag or meta description, technical error, or low-quality content.

Since different websites serve different goals and cater to different segments of audiences, there is no one-size-fits-all solution to reducing bounce rate. A/B testing will help you find friction and pain points to improve your visitors’ experience, which will, in turn, improve bounce rate.

Make low-risk modifications

A/B testing allows you to make minor adjustments to your pages instead of redesigning the entire website and jeopardizing your conversion rate. This is helpful if you don’t know whether the change will have a positive effect on the user experience. If you plan on making a change to your website, say, updating product descriptions, you can run an A/B test to analyze users’ reaction and decide whether to make it permanent or not.

A/B testing & SEO

Although it’s a good idea to run tests to better understand how your audience interacts with your website, it is possible to jeopardize your rank if they’re poorly managed.

No cloaking

Cloaking is the practice of showing one set of content to humans and another to Googlebot. This is against Google’s Webmaster Guidelines, whether you’re running a test or not. Make sure that you’re not deciding which content variant to serve based on user-agent or IP address. Infringing Google’s guidelines can get your site demoted or even removed from search results.

Only use 302 redirects

If you’re running an A/B test that redirects users from the original URL to a variation URL, use a 302 temporary redirect, not a 301 permanent redirect. This tells the search engines that this redirect is temporary and that they should keep the original URL in their index rather than replacing it with the test page.

Run experiments for the appropriate duration

Running tests for longer than necessary can be seen as an attempt to deceive search engines. The amount of time required for a reliable test will vary depending on factors like your conversion rates and how much traffic your website gets. A good testing tool will tell you when you’ve gathered enough data to draw reliable conclusions. Once you have concluded the test, update your site and remove all elements of the test as soon as possible.

Use rel=”canonical” links

If you run an A/B test with multiple URLs, Google suggests using the rel=“canonical” link attribute on all alternate URLs to highlight that the original URL is preferred. This will prevent Googlebot from getting confused by multiple versions of the same page. For instance, if you are testing variations of a page, you don’t want search engines not to index that page. You just want them to understand that the test URLs are variations of the original URL and should be grouped together, with the original URL as the hero.

How to perform A/B testing

A/B testing isn’t complicated, but you need a strategy before you begin.

Conduct usability testing

Before building an A/B test, you need to conduct thorough research on how the website is currently performing. You will have to collect quantitative and qualitative data to understand how users are currently using the website, such as how many users visit per day, which pages drive the most traffic, how long users spend on each page, and more.

Use Google Analytics to track quantitative data such as traffic, referral sources, and other valuable information.

Qualitative insights can be derived from tools that collect data on visitor behavior. Heatmap tools, such as Crazy Egg, are used to determine users’ scrolling and click behavior.

The purpose of this testing is to produce a more systematic understanding of how users interact with your site. Collecting this data will provide insight into problem areas where you can begin optimizing. Look for pages with low conversion rates or high bounce rates that can be improved. When you know how users are responding to your current strategy and what areas need improvement, you can start A/B testing.

Set goals

What do you want to achieve with your A/B test? Your conversion goals are the metrics that you are using to determine whether or not the variation is more successful than the original. A goal could be a higher conversion rate, lower bounce rate, lower cart abandonment, or increased traffic.

Determine the element you want to test

Start with a single element you want to test relevant to your goal. For instance, if you want to generate more organic traffic, you could test the length of title tags and meta descriptions. For a higher conversion rate, you might begin with the headline or CTA.

Headlines and copywriting

The headline is the first thing users see when they arrive on a web page. If it doesn’t grab visitors’ attention, they won’t stick around. Ensure that it’s short, catchy, and to-the-point.

The body of your website should clearly state what the visitor is getting. A well-written body can significantly increase conversions.

Try A/B testing different fonts, paragraph lengths and writing styles, and analyze which compels visitors to convert.

Forms

One of the reasons most frequently cited for forms being abandoned is that they are too complicated. More than 67% of site visitors will abandon a form if they encounter any complications.

There’s plenty of data that shows that users like shorter forms. Create a shorter variation to test against the original. Some fields may be essential, like email address, while others are optional. Eliminate the optional fields as they may create bottlenecks.

Field bottlenecks are fields that keep a user from completing a form. For example, you might require users to enter their phone number, resulting in a high bottleneck rate if they’re reluctant to give it. Test for bottlenecks and remove them if possible.

Anything that slows users down can increase abandonment, so it’s important to avoid fields that break their rhythm. Avoid asking for information that makes your users question why you’re asking for it. If they feel like you’re asking for something unnecessary, there’s a good chance they’ll abandon the form. If you need something special, make sure to explain why. For example, if you want to ask for the user’s company name, be clear that your form is business related.

CTAs

The call to action (CTA) tells users what you want them to do. Most of the time, it determines whether users convert or not.

Changing even one word in your CTA can influence conversion rates. Other characteristics such as button color, text color, contrast, size, and placement also impact performance. Such experimentation helps understand which has the potential to get the most conversions.

Subject lines

Email subject lines directly impact open rates. If a subscriber doesn’t see anything they like, the email will likely wind up in the trash bin.

A/B testing subject lines can increase your chances of getting users to click. Test questions versus statements, power words against one another, and copy with and without emojis.

Content depth

Some visitors prefer reading long-form content pieces while others just like to skim through the page and deep dive only into the topics that are most relevant to them.

If you are unsure how to write content for your audience, test different versions of your content. To test content depth, create two pieces of the same content. One will be significantly longer than the other and provide deeper insight. Then, analyze which compels your readers the most.

Product descriptions

Unlike content depth, consumers prefer simple, easy-to-digest product descriptions. Test longer descriptions against shorter ones to see which converts better. Additionally, you can test product description design. For example, test paragraph copy against bullet points.

Social proof

Social proof may take the form of recommendations and reviews from experts of the particular fields, from customers themselves, or can come as testimonials, media mentions, awards, and so on. Displaying social proof on your landing pages can increase conversions, but only if you present it in an appealing way. For example, test star ratings against testimonials.

Landing pages/ design and layout

Your landing pages need to convert users. If they don’t, you lose a potential sale. Declutter your pages using insights from heatmaps, clickmaps, and scrollmaps. The less cluttered your landing pages, the easier it is for visitors to find what they’re looking for.

To the untrained marketer, everything may seem essential. While this isn’t true, business owners sometimes struggle with determining the most essential elements on their website.

Formulate a hypothesis

After you’ve drawn website and user insights and determined what you want your test to accomplish, create a hypothesis. A hypothesis is a prediction you create prior to running an experiment. It states clearly what is being changed, what you believe the outcome will be, and why you think that’s the case. This is where the importance of having data comes in handy.

A complete hypothesis has three parts. The variable, desired result, and rationale are the three elements of your hypothesis that should be researched and documented prior to testing.

Create a variant

Next, create a variant based on your hypothesis to test against your control. Change only the element you decided on in the previous step and make only one change to it. This might be changing the color of a button, swapping the order of elements on the page, or something entirely custom. Keep in mind that simple changes can drive big improvements.

Run the A/B test

At this point, visitors will be randomly assigned to either the control or variation. While your test is running, make sure it meets every requirement to produce statistically significant results, like testing on accurate traffic and for the correct duration.

Running a test for too long or short a time can produce statistically insignificant results. Make sure that you let your test run long enough to obtain a substantial sample size. Otherwise, it'll be hard to tell whether there was a statistically significant difference between the variations. The duration for which you need to run the test depends on existing traffic, existing conversion rate, expected improvement, and more. For example, if your website receives a lot of traffic, you will receive results much faster than a website with less traffic.

Analyze results

Once your experiment is complete, it's time to analyze the results. Interpreting test results is extremely important to understand why the test succeeded. To understand your test results, look back to the metrics you used to analyze user behavior. If one variation is statistically better than the other, you have a winner. If neither variation is statistically better, you've just learned that the variable didn't impact results and the test was inconclusive. After you’ve considered the results, deploy the winning variation.

A/B testing is invaluable when it comes to improving your website’s conversion rates. It may seem like an easy experimentation process, however, it’s a complex procedure that requires patience, persistence, and precision. The more thorough you are with your research, planning, and hypothesis development, the better test you’ll create.

Are you A/B testing your website?

Let's Talk

Join our newsletter
Hoist Logo Mark