Want to get updates to your mailbox? 📬

Subscribe to our newsletter!

We don't spam. You will only receive relevant and important tips for you and your business.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Why Small Business Owners Shouldn't Manage Google Ads Themselves

By Ryan Boog

TL;DR

  • Google Ads can generate real leads for small businesses, but self-managed campaigns routinely waste budget through avoidable mistakes.
  • Google's beginner tools (Smart Campaigns, auto-recommendations) are designed to make you spend more, not perform better.
  • A well-structured campaign requires audience targeting, negative keywords, landing page alignment, and ongoing optimization.
  • If you're running Google Ads without campaign management experience, you're likely paying more per lead than you should be.

Why Small Business Owners Shouldn't Manage Google Ads Themselves

What Is Google Ads and How Does It Work for Small Businesses?

Google Ads is an auction-based advertising platform that places your business in front of people actively searching for what you offer. You select keywords, write ads, set a budget, and pay when someone clicks. Ads can appear on Google Search, Google Maps, YouTube, and millions of partner websites.

For small businesses, the appeal is straightforward: show up when someone searches "emergency plumber near me" or "best tax preparer in [city]" and pay only when they click and visit your website.

The problem isn't the platform. It's the gap between setting up an account and running a campaign that actually delivers a return.

Why Google Wants You to Manage Ads Yourself (And Why That's a Problem)

Google actively encourages small business owners to manage their own ads. The platform offers guided setup wizards, pre-populated keyword suggestions, AI-generated ad copy, and "Smart Campaigns" that promise hands-off management.

This sounds like a great feature. But it functions like a liability.

Google earns revenue every time someone clicks an ad, whether or not that click becomes a customer. Their incentive is for you to spend; they care less about your conversion rate.

Auto-recommendations frequently push higher bids, broader keyword match types, and expanded targeting, all of which increase impressions and clicks without necessarily improving lead quality.

Never let Google auto-apply. It’s the closest thing to a 'self-destruct' button in marketing.

What to watch for:

  • Recommendations to "expand your reach" by adding broad match keywords
  • Prompts to increase your daily budget "to reach more customers"
  • Smart Campaign defaults that hide search term reports and granular targeting controls

What Does a Poorly Managed Google Ad Actually Look Like?

Bad ads don't just underperform, they cost money while doing it. Here are three failure patterns common in self-managed campaigns.

Failure Pattern 1: Errors in Ad Copy

A single typo in an ad headline signals carelessness to potential customers and wastes every click that ad receives. Ads with spelling or grammatical errors consistently show lower click-through rates and quality scores, which also drives up your cost per click. Example of a poor Google Ads ad that contains an obvious misspelling of Minnesota Mistake: Minioseta? Have you ever been to Minioseta? Me neither. Google doesn't catch spelling errors. But your competitors and potential customers do.

Failure Pattern 2: Missing Ad Extensions (Now Called Ad Assets)

Google Ads allows advertisers to add sitelinks, callouts, location info, phone numbers, and structured snippets to ads at no extra cost. These extensions increase ad size, improve click-through rates, and give searchers more reasons to choose you before they even reach your website.

An ad that shows only a headline and two lines of description is leaving significant real estate, and likely significant revenue, on the table. Example of a poorly optimized Google Ads ad that lacks sitelinks and other features

Mistake: No part of this ad is optimized. The only thing this company has is “Call Us Today”. This ad is missing out on explaining their services, qualifications, and offers. There is a lot of information that can be added.

What Makes a High-Performing Google Ad?

A well-constructed ad earns attention, communicates value, and filters for the right audience. Every part of a Google ad has a job. Here's what each one does. Example of a great Google Ad for Royal Pool & Spa

The Technical Setup Most Small Business Owners Skip

Running Google Ads effectively requires decisions that never appear in a Smart Campaign dashboard.

Keyword Match Types Determine Who Sees Your Ad

Google offers three match types: broad, phrase, and exact. Broad match — the default — can show your ad for searches that are loosely related to your keyword.

A plumber bidding on "pipe repair" with broad match might show up for "pipe dream definition" or "PVC pipe wholesale."

Phrase and exact match give you control. They cost more per click in some cases, but the clicks convert better. Most beginner campaigns over-rely on broad match and wonder why their traffic doesn't turn into leads.

Negative Keywords Prevent Wasted Spend

Negative keywords tell Google when not to show your ad. Without them, a local HVAC company might pay for clicks from people searching for DIY repair guides, job listings, or equipment wholesale, none of whom are potential customers.

Building a negative keyword list before launching a campaign, and adding to it weekly based on your search terms report, is standard practice in managed campaigns and almost universally skipped in DIY setups.

Landing Pages Determine Whether Clicks Become Customers

Sending paid traffic to your homepage is one of the most common and costly mistakes in Google Ads. Effective campaigns direct each ad group to a dedicated landing page that mirrors the ad's message, focuses on a single conversion action, and eliminates navigation distractions.

Google also uses landing page experience as part of its Quality Score algorithm — a measure that directly affects your cost per click.

A poor landing page means you pay more for every click than a competitor with a better page.

Ad Scheduling and Geo-Targeting Reduce Wasted Budget

Most small businesses don't need to run ads 24/7 or nationally. Limiting ad delivery to business hours, specific zip codes, and radius targeting around your location focuses budget where it's most likely to convert.

These settings are available in standard campaigns but bypassed entirely in Smart Campaigns.

How Much Does a Poorly Managed Campaign Actually Cost You?

The waste in an unoptimized Google Ads campaign comes from multiple directions simultaneously:

  • Irrelevant clicks from broad match keywords with no negatives
  • Low Quality Scores from mismatched landing pages, paying a premium per click
  • Duplicate assets that hide your strongest selling points
  • No conversion tracking, so you're optimizing for clicks instead of leads

The question isn't whether Google Ads works for small businesses. It does.

The question is whether the return justifies the spend, and that depends almost entirely on how the campaign is built and managed.

What Professional Google Ads Management Actually Includes

A managed campaign isn't just setup. It's an ongoing process of testing, refinement, and optimization against actual business goals.

Typical scope of professional management:

  • Keyword research tied to buyer intent, not just volume
  • Campaign architecture: ad groups organized by service, location, or audience segment
  • Ad copywriting with A/B testing across multiple variants
  • Extension build-out: sitelinks, callouts, location, call, price, and promotion extensions
  • Negative keyword management from day one
  • Conversion tracking setup (phone calls, form fills, purchases)
  • Landing page review and recommendations
  • Weekly search term audits
  • Monthly performance reporting with actionable insights
  • Bid strategy adjustments based on actual conversion data

Should You Use Google Ads at All?

Google Ads works best when:

  • Your service or product has clear, searchable demand
  • Your average customer value justifies a cost per lead of $30–$200+
  • You have a functional, fast, mobile-friendly website or landing page
  • You have conversion tracking in place so you can measure results
  • You have the budget to test and optimize (typically $1,000–$3,000/month minimum)

If those conditions aren't in place, Google Ads spend will likely generate clicks, and little else.

Need an honest assessment of your current Google Ads account?

Contact Hoist for a campaign audit.

Join our
newsletter

For all of the latest news and trends related to your B2C business