Want to get updates to your mailbox? 📬

Subscribe to our newsletter!

We don't spam. You will only receive relevant and important tips for you and your business.

Unsubscribe anytime.

3 Reasons Why You Aren't Ranking #1 On Google

By Darren DeYoung

If you’ve ever asked yourself, “Why aren’t my ranking results on Google showing up at the top?” you’re not alone. Businesses often track their keyword ranking history, but many still struggle to claim that coveted #1 spot.

The truth is, your rankings are not as fixed or universal as you might think. Google tailors results in ways that can make your position look different depending on who is searching, where they are, and what device they’re on.

Let’s break down three common reasons why your Google search term ranking may not match what you expect and what you can do about it.

3 Reasons Why You Aren't Ranking #1 On Google

Personalization: Why Rankings May Differ for Everyone

Google customizes results for each user. That means two people searching the same keyword at the same time may see different ranking results.

Here’s why:

  • Device type – Mobile vs. desktop results can look different.
  • Search location – Your physical location heavily influences rankings, especially for local businesses.
  • Previous searches & clicks – Google remembers your activity and adjusts future results.

For example, I searched for “bass” and got this:

Google Search results for Bass

Below the first organic result for the G.H. Bass & Co. is a number of fishing-related websites. I visited a few of those websites. I then opened a new tab and searched for “bass” again:

Google Search Result for Bass the fish

Well, what do you know, information about the bass fish is displayed in the knowledge panel. Google has “personalized” my search results based on past search behavior. Ironically, it also provided a link for more results on the bass guitar, as well.

Personalized search has been around since 2005, whether you are signed in to a Google account or not. Bing and Yahoo personalize their search results as well.

If you are signed in under a Google account, your search results are even more personalized. Because Google has more information about you from your accounts, your results will be even more relevant.

Google creates a personalized profile for every searcher based on their browsing history, search history, which websites they click on from the search results page, and then alters the future search results based on these interests. They also draw information from all Google products that you use:

  • Gmail
  • Google Calendar
  • Google Play
  • Google Maps
  • etc.

All Google products have information about you and your interests and Google uses this information to personalize your search results and to provide a better experience.

It is possible to turn off personalized search, but Google can still personalize searches based on your geographic location, which we’ll discuss later.

Mobile vs Desktop: How Does Your Device Impact Search Rankings?

Man looking at his mobile phone with a laptop computer in the background
More people are searching on mobile devices than ever before. Google prioritizes mobile-friendly websites, meaning if your site isn’t optimized for smartphones, your rankings could drop on those devices.

A mobile-friendly website is huge! It loads quickly, adjusts to screen sizes, and avoids features like Flash that don’t work on mobile. If your competitors have optimized sites and you don’t, their results will show above yours for mobile users.

Today, websites need to focus on mobile to provide a better user experience.

Location: Why You Might Not Be Ranking First in Google Results

Map of the world with five colored pins on it
Search engines heavily weigh location when displaying results. That’s why a user in Minneapolis might see your business in the top 3, while someone searching in Dallas won’t.

Google pulls in local map listings, business directories, and other region-specific results. If you’re not optimizing your local SEO (such as Google Business Profile, local citations, and reviews), you’ll struggle to rank consistently in different areas.

Why You Aren’t Ranking First (and What to Do About It)

There are no consistent Google rankings or search experiences across users, locations, or devices. So if your keyword ranking history shows ups and downs, don’t panic—that’s normal.

Here’s what you can do:

  • Track rankings over time, not just a single snapshot.
  • Focus on long-term SEO strategies (content, backlinks, technical fixes).
  • Optimize for both desktop and mobile searches.
  • Strengthen local SEO for consistent visibility in your target market.

Improving your ranking results on Google isn’t about chasing one perfect spot, it’s about building a strong foundation that performs across devices and locations.

Final Thoughts

Ranking #1 on Google isn’t a one-time win, it’s a moving target. By focusing on mobile optimization, tracking your keyword ranking history, and strengthening local SEO, you’ll improve visibility where it matters most: in front of your customers.

👉 Need help boosting your Google search term ranking?

Contact our team to get a tailored SEO strategy that gets real results.

Join our
newsletter

For all of the latest news and trends related to your B2C business